On Thursday, May 25, 2017, PCSO Homicide detectives arrested: 

39-year-old Christopher Clardy, DOB 6/28/77, 2401 Teri Street, Auburndale

• First Degree Murder (F-C)
• Conspiracy to Commit First Degree Murder (F-1)
• Possession of a Firearm by a Convicted Felon (F-2)

30-year-old Jamie “Jamo” Garst, DOB 11/21/86, 447 Skyline Drive West, Lakeland

• First Degree Murder (F-C)
• Conspiracy to Commit First Degree Murder (F-1)
• Possession of a Firearm by a Convicted Felon (F-2)
• Tampering with Evidence (F-3)

According to their affidavits and previously released information, on May 10, 2017, Preston Burnett’s body was found by a man out walking near the woods on Skyview Blvd in Lakeland. Preston had been shot to death, according to the autopsy. Preston was last seen on Teri Street in Auburndale, where he was taken by an Auburndale Police Corporal after being seen sleeping on a bench in downtown Auburndale.

Preston was killed between 3:15 and 3:30 p.m. on May 10, 2017, in the location where he was found (near the dead end of Skyview Blvd). The area serves as a cut-through that connects Skyview Blvd to the Secret Cove subdivision.

PCSO released photos that were found at the scene, of two unknown women. The women were positively identified as Julie Roderus and her mother. Julie was in jail at the time. Detectives interviewed her and were able to identify her boyfriend, Jamie “Jamo” Garst, who drives a gray Buick.

A gray Buick was seen on video surveillance heading northbound on Skyview Blvd on the day of the homicide. It never exited back out the way it came, leading detectives to believe it traveled on the “cut-through” path out of Secret Cove.

On May 25, 2017, a PCSO deputy sheriff conducted a traffic stop on Garst’s Buick. Post-Miranda, he told them the following:

• He was at his residence, 447 Skyline Drive in Lakeland on May 10^th when Chris Clardy, Preston Burnett (the victim), and two others arrived at the house. At some point, Preston asked for a ride to Lakeland. Garst, Clardy, and Preston got in the Buick and drove down Skyview Boulevard and onto the cut-through which connects Skyview Boulevard to the Secret Cove subdivision.

• Garst drove onto the grassy pathway then stopped. Clardy got out, opened Preston’s door, and told him to get out.

• Clardy shot Preston Burnett multiple times and then dragged him a few feet off the path.

• Garst told deputies he made two cell phone recordings of the murder—before and during the shooting.

• He told detectives the gun used to kill Preston belonged to him (Garst).

• He told detectives Clardy told him he was coming over and that he needed to “get rid of this guy” meaning Preston. A short time later, Clardy and Preston arrived at Garst’s residence on Skyline Drive West in Lakeland.

PCSO detectives retrieved the cell phone recordings of the murder. They show Preston standing on the passenger side of the car, and Clardy standing behind the car talking to Preston. Clardy can be heard saying, “I told you not to come back here,” and “I told you what was going to happen to you the next time you came back.” Shots can be heard on the video.

PCSO detectives recovered the firearm used in the homicide, and obtained an arrest warrant for Clardy. During the early morning hours of Friday, May 26, 2017, detectives located and arrested Clardy, and interviewed him. 

Post-Miranda, Clardy initially told detectives that Garst killed Preston. Later, after listening to the audio from the cell phone recording, he made a full confession. He told detectives that he killed Preston because of the way Preston treated Clardy’s family.  

Jamie Garst’s criminal history includes:

• August 2010 – arrested by LPD for 2 counts aggravated battery with a deadly weapon
• December 2013 – arrested by PCSO for robbery and VOP

Christopher Clardy’s criminal history includes:

• July 1997 – arrested by PCSO for possession of short-barreled shotgun and money laundering
• August 2010 – arrested by PCSO for aggravated assault with deadly weapon
• November 2011 – arrested by PSO for possession of controlled substance without prescription, possession of marijuana, possession of paraphernalia
• February 2012 – arrested by PCSO for FTA
• April 2012 – arrested by PCSO for DWLSR, possession of drugs WITS, possession of paraphernalia, smuggling contraband into detention facility
• August 2012 – arrested by PCSO for aggravated assault with deadly weapon, domestic battery, burglary, possession of burglary tools with intent to use, larceny grand theft, VOP
• February 2013 – arrested by PCSO for petit theft, possession of controlled substance without prescription, possession of paraphernalia, burglary, VOP
• March 2016 – arrested by HCSO for grand theft, fraud, dealing in stolen property